October 10, 2022 • 4 Min Read

White Label or Platform – Which Is Right for Your Reg. A+? - StartEngine

White Label or Platform – Which Is Right for Your Reg. A+? - StartEngine

Today, the benefits of equity crowdfunding are clear. 

Traditionally, to get capital you would find a VC, institutional investor, or go raise money through angels and accredited investors. It’s a time consuming process that can take hundreds of hours and sometimes leave you out to dry with nothing. Or, maybe you do get a term sheet – and hopefully the terms are favorable – but when the timing is bad that term sheet can be pulled right out from underneath you.

By contrast, equity crowdfunding has changed this narrative in a big way. How? Well, you can raise up to $5M per year under Reg. CF or up to $75M per year under Reg. A+. You stay in control – for instance, by issuing non-voting common shares. And you manage the entire fundraising process one investor at a time – after all, it’s often easier to get lots of small and medium checks than one giant check. 

Despite all of equity crowdfunding’s upsides, though, Reg. A+ in particular has not necessarily been successful for many entrepreneurs. Why? It all comes down to choices. Say you decide to raise $10M using a Reg. A+. Now you have two options: hire a broker-dealer platform to organize and run your offering; or, go the DIY route. Let’s unpack both and see which might be best for you.

Option 1: Hire a broker-dealer platform, like StartEngine

The more standard, and in my view fruitful, choice is to hire a broker-dealer platform, such as StartEngine, SeedInvest or Republic, to name a few. These platforms offer a full range of services for companies raising under Reg. A+. So what do you get? Here’s what’s typically part of the full-service offering:

  • Structuring of the deal and the type of securities to be offered
  • Sourcing the escrow service, transfer agent, legal team, and CPAs
  • Ensuring SEC compliance, reviewing past filings, and making updates if needed
  • Preparing a marketing and launch plan for the offering – this can sometimes include a test-the-waters campaign to build interest as well

Broker-dealer platforms often also come with regulatory advantages – notably, they can generally offer in all 50 states and manage state filings as well as any state-specific requirements. (It’s important to note, though, that every broker-dealer may be different).

The most important aspect of a platform is the quality of their investor community. In my experience, average investor acquisition costs hover right around $2,000. So the number of repeat investors a broker-dealer platform brings can make a huge difference in the success of your offering. Additionally, as investors place their orders, the platform will check each one against Treasury regulation requirements (aka your customer and anti money-laundering checks).

Some of the largest raises to date have been conducted with broker-dealer platforms. And the comfort of knowing all regulations are met, as well as the boost to momentum from a dedicated investor community, are huge advantages. For these services, a company will often pay around 3.5%, plus some equity compensation. Sometimes investors pay fees as well, though in the case of StartEngine, escrow fees are included.

Option 2: Do It Yourself

Though it’s called a DIY offering, in practice it’s often in name only. Generally, a company will look for a white-label platform that can help with presenting the offering and the mechanics for accepting investments as a service. This saves the need to write all of the website and back-end code to receive investments into an escrow account. Most businesses will also hire a low-cost broker-dealer to handle the clearing of investments, such as KYC/AML, on their behalf.

The costs for these off-the-shelf solutions vary. In my experience, though, the white-label gets around $10 per investor, and the accommodating broker-dealer gets about 1% plus $50k in fixed fees. Don’t forget – escrow may be another 1.5% depending on the vendors and banks selected. So all in, your costs can be up to 4.5% or more depending on the size of your raise. However, the main disadvantage is the hefty cost to acquire new investors. Remember the $2,000 average? That means unless you already have a highly engaged community, advertising will likely not work on its own.

The right solution? A combination of the two.

I’ve found that broker-dealer platforms, like StartEngine, can typically offer 50% of the investors a company needs; the other half is acquired through the business’s own efforts. So, why not start with a platform, like ours, to get to your goal? Then, down the road hire a separate white-label and broker-dealer to build on the raise. Now, some may argue that it’s best to simply engage your own community via a white-label first, then switch to a platform (in other words, turn the process around). But you have to remember the key is momentum. At StartEngine, we’ve learned that investors look for early signs of a hot raise – so if you get a slow start, you could be dead in the water.

Raising capital is hard. Equity crowdfunding can make it a lot easier, but only if you pick the right partner. My advice? Do your homework, and go with a high-reputation team to mitigate the risks of a low-performing offer.

Ready to raise capital for your company?

Join thousands of companies that have raised over $1 billion on StartEngine. Get funded by your community.

Related Articles

Equity crowdfunding has emerged as a transformative force in the world of finance, offering entrepreneurs and investors…

Crowdfunding has become an increasingly popular way for entrepreneurs and small businesses to raise capital in the…

In the ever-evolving landscape of business financing, entrepreneurs and small business owners are faced with a crucial…

Ready to raise capital for your company?

Join thousands of companies that have raised over $1 billion on StartEngine. Get funded by your community.